Back to Blog

Which clients are actually worth your time? Profitability by the hour

Revenue per client tells you who pays the most. Revenue per hour tells you who pays the best. They are rarely the same client, and the second list is the one that should shape your year.

Ask a freelancer who their best client is and they will name the one who pays the biggest invoices. Ask them which client is the most profitable per hour and most cannot answer, because the two numbers live in different places: revenue in the accounting software, hours in the time tracker, and nobody has put them side by side. When you do, the ranking usually changes. The big client with endless calls and three-round revisions drops. The quiet one with clear briefs climbs to the top. Client profitability by the hour is the number that should decide where your next year goes.

The calculation

For each client, over the last six or twelve months: total amount invoiced divided by total hours logged for that client, including every non-billable hour, which means calls, emails, chasing payment, and revisions you did not charge for. That is your effective hourly rate with that client. It is almost always lower than your listed rate, and the spread between clients is often two to one.

You can do this in a spreadsheet, but it only works if the hours are complete. A client who generates a lot of untracked "quick questions" will look more profitable than they are. This is the strongest argument for logging non-billable time: without it, your most demanding clients are invisible in exactly the way that costs you most. If you have not been doing that, the post on billable vs. non-billable hours explains how to start.

Reading the list

Sort your clients by effective rate and look at the ends.

At the top are clients who pay close to your listed rate. They tend to brief clearly, approve quickly, and pay on time, which is not a coincidence: those behaviors are what keep the non-billable hours low. These are the clients to ask for referrals, to offer a retainer, and to protect when your calendar is full.

At the bottom are clients whose effective rate is half the others. Before you fire anyone, find out why. There are three usual causes, and each has a different fix:

  • Underpriced from the start. You quoted low to win them and never corrected it. Fix: the rate increase you have been putting off, with 30 days' notice.
  • Scope that grew. The fee stayed fixed while the work expanded. Fix: re-scope at the next project, with revision rounds and change requests defined and priced.
  • Overhead you cannot bill. Weekly status calls, slow approvals, invoices that need three reminders. Fix: name the overhead and either charge for it (a project management line, a late fee) or change the process (async updates instead of calls, a deposit before work starts).

Only when none of those fixes is possible is the answer to let the client go. Even then, do it by not renewing rather than by quitting mid-project, and only once the hours they free up have somewhere better to go.

Where the hours actually went

The reports page in Gigtime lets you filter to a single client and see hours by project and by billable status, which answers the "why" faster than a spreadsheet can. A client whose non-billable share is 35 percent when everyone else sits at 15 is a client with an overhead problem, and the entry descriptions will tell you whether it is calls, revisions, or chasing. Export the filtered report if you want to keep the numbers next to your invoices, or schedule it monthly so the comparison happens without you remembering to run it.

Do it once a quarter

Effective rate per client is not a daily metric. It moves slowly, and checking it too often turns normal variation into anxiety. Once a quarter is right: enough data for the numbers to mean something, often enough to act before a bad client eats another six months. Put it next to your quarterly tax estimate; both are about the same thing, which is knowing what your time is actually worth.

A worked example

Two clients, same listed rate of $90. Client A paid $14,400 over the year against 160 logged hours, 140 of them billable: an effective rate of $90, right on the number, because the 20 unbilled hours were a handful of short calls. Client B paid $27,000, nearly twice as much, against 410 logged hours, of which 300 were billable: an effective rate of $66. The extra 110 hours were weekly status calls, three rounds of revisions on every deliverable, and two months of chasing a late invoice. On paper B is the bigger client. Per hour, A pays 36 percent more, and the 110 hours B absorbed would have been another $9,900 at A's rate. That is the number to bring to the next scoping conversation with B.

The hardest part is the first time, because it requires the hours to exist. Try Gigtime free for 30 days, log everything for a month, and run the numbers. You may be surprised which client wins.